Skip to content
WattWise

Solar Payback Calculator (No Federal Credit)

Use a proposal and a location-specific production estimate. The model uses your own rates, export rules and costs.

Fields marked as examples are starting values only. Federal incentives default to zero.

Production estimate: NREL PVWatts.

No federal credit is assumed. Enter only incentives you have independently confirmed; program eligibility and utility export rules vary and change.

Translate a proposal into model inputs

System size is the proposed DC capacity in kilowatts. Installed cost per watt is multiplied by 1,000 watts per kilowatt and system size to get project cost. The incentives field reduces that initial amount only when you enter a confirmed amount; it starts at zero because WattWise assumes no federal credit. First-year kWh per kW should come from a location-specific estimate. PVWatts can model a system using location, orientation and loss assumptions, but it is still an estimate rather than a production guarantee.

The model separates energy used in the home from energy exported. It multiplies the self-consumed share by your imported electricity rate and exported share by the export credit you enter. Annual production declines by the degradation assumption, while the imported rate changes by the escalation assumption. Each year's gross value is reduced by recurring operations and maintenance and by a one-time inverter expense in the year you specify. The table accumulates annual net values against the net upfront cost.

Example calculation using hypothetical inputs

Consider an illustrative 5 kW system at $3 per watt, with no incentive entered. Initial cost is 5 × 1,000 × $3 = $15,000. If a user enters 1,200 kWh per kW in year one, production is 6,000 kWh. With 70% self-use at 18¢/kWh and 30% exports credited at 5¢/kWh, gross annual value is 4,200 × $0.18 + 1,800 × $0.05 = $846. Subtracting a hypothetical $100 annual operating cost gives $746 in year one. That does not establish whether a real system pays back; later years follow the assumptions entered in the form.

How payback and the long table work

Simple payback is the point at which cumulative net value first offsets net initial cost. When the balance crosses zero between annual entries, the displayed year fraction linearly interpolates within that year's net contribution. This is a simple, undiscounted calculation. The 25-year net figure is all modeled annual net values less initial cost, so it can be negative. If the cumulative balance never reaches zero, the tool says payback is not within 25 years. With a zero production yield, annual energy value is zero and ongoing costs can make the cumulative position worse. A system size of zero kW is rejected because there would be nothing to pay back.

The break-even starting rate solves for the imported rate that makes the modeled 25-year cumulative balance reach zero, holding the other assumptions constant. It accounts for the assumed escalation and export credit. If no non-negative starting rate can produce payback under the entered production, costs and fixed export credit within the horizon, it reports that no modeled rate is feasible. This output is highly sensitive to assumptions and is not a forecast of future tariffs.

What the model leaves out

Actual project economics can include loan interest, lease or power-purchase terms, roof work, insurance, taxes, inverter warranties, outages, utility fixed charges, curtailment, changing export compensation, and the value of a home sale. The model does not discount future dollars for inflation or opportunity cost. Annual escalation is a user-selected scenario, not a prediction. Export shares and rates may vary by season or hour, and a utility tariff can change. Use the current tariff and ask the utility how credits are settled.

Do not treat the incentive field as a rebate finder. The IRS states that the Residential Clean Energy Credit applies to qualifying expenditures made through December 31, 2025 and is not available for expenditures after that date; verify current IRS instructions and any applicable carryforward details. State, local and utility programs vary; DSIRE is a directory, not a guarantee of eligibility. Common mistakes include entering AC production as if it were the same as a DC-specific estimate, mixing cents with dollars, overlooking export compensation, and assuming every produced kWh offsets a retail-priced purchase. Use the solar payback guide alongside a current proposal.

Frequently asked questions

Does the solar calculator include a federal credit?

No. The upfront incentive field starts at zero and only holds an amount you have confirmed yourself. The IRS says the Residential Clean Energy Credit applies to expenditures made through December 31, 2025.

Where do I get first-year production?

Enter kWh per kW from a location-specific estimate. NREL’s PVWatts calculator is the standard free tool, and production depends on location, tilt, shading and system losses. The 1,200 kWh per kW default is only an example, and the tool accepts up to 3,000.

How is the first-year value calculated?

Production is split between self-used energy valued at your imported rate and exports valued at your export credit. In a hypothetical 5 kW system at $3 per watt, 6,000 kWh with 70% self-use at 18¢ and 30% exported at 5¢ is $846, or $746 after $100 of upkeep.

What does “not within 25 years” mean?

The cumulative modeled net value never reached the net initial cost during the 25-year table. The result is simple and undiscounted, and the 25-year net figure can be negative.

What is the break-even starting rate?

It is the imported rate at which the modeled 25-year balance reaches zero, holding other inputs constant. If the project already pays back within 25 years even at a 0 cent rate, the tool says so.

Which inputs are checked?

Inputs must be numbers and non-negative, and system size must be above zero kW. Export share is 0–100%, degradation is below 100%, the inverter year is a whole number from 0 to 25 (0 means none) and escalation is up to 100% per year.

Sources and further reading